The Rainie Treatment
Wanderings & wonderings of a public school administrator
The Rainie Treatment
Navigation
  • About Me
  • Resources

What I’m Reading: Some Students Should Go To School, Most Should Stay Home

22 July 2020 | Filed under: Leadership, What I'm Reading and tagged with: equity, pandemic, quarantine, racism, What Im Reading

Over the weekend, I read this Medium post by Dr. Shayla R. Griffin, “Some Students Should Go To School, Most Should Stay Home.” In it, Dr. Griffin highlights the crisis of the schooling decision facing all communities right now: remote learning has serious weaknesses, but in-person instruction presents significant risks right now in the face of a global pandemic. Of particular concern, the students most at-risk in remote learning—students who struggle to learn, who aren’t connected to school, who require social services such as free or reduced-price lunch—are the same population most at risk of serious health or life impacts if exposed to COVID-19 by holding school in-person. These groups are disproportionately represented by students of color, who are more at risk of serious bodily damage from coronavirus, and who are dealing with the dual crisis of having their status outside the mainstream curriculum exposed and analyzed right now. Hopefully, this anti-racist work will lead to improved circumstances, but it certainly reinforces the concern that students of color are “damned if you, damned if you don’t” return to school buildings in the fall.

Dr. Griffin launches from a paradigm that rejects either/or thinking and urges both/and thinking. To her point, the coronavirus puts students of color at risk both from serious health complications for them or their older family members and from widening gaps in educational access. It puts low socioeconomic status students at risk both from loss of access to school meals and to a safe school environment and from limited healthcare and depressed health outcomes for their friends, relatives, or selves who become sick. In the face of such an enemy, wielding both/and attacks, any reasonable solution can not be penned in by either/or thinking.

Dr. Griffin lays out a 6-part approach to schooling, based in acknowledging that most students will be able to succeed in a remote learning model, with appropriate planning, provisions, preparation, and progress-monitoring. For students at risk of either (a) not succeeding in this model (for example, those who would be unable to learn from observing lectures or reading), or (b) not getting their needs for basic food, shelter, and safety met without an in-school option, there will need to be an in-person schooling model with robust safety protocols. Part of that safety plan will involve strictly limiting the population in this category to support social distancing by those who most need to be there.

Implementing such a plan will certainly invite criticism that it isn’t “fair” that some people can choose in-school or remote learning, while others don’t have access to the former option, but as we know, what’s fair is often unequal. To paraphrase Jane Elliott, if anyone would prefer to have both options available to their, all they have to do is switch places with them. Anyone choosing to take on the burden of systemic racism, debilitating health complications, harrowing poverty, or disability, in order to lift another family to a life of relative comfort and lessened concerns, can reasonably argue that their child should be considered for coming to school in the middle of a pandemic.

Related

Share

Did you like this article? Share it with your friends!

Tweet

Written by Damon Rainie

Follow me on Twitter

2 Responses to "What I’m Reading: Some Students Should Go To School, Most Should Stay Home"

  1. What do we need from schools in September? – The Rainie Treatment says:
    27 July 2020 at 7:41 pm

    […] few weeks ago, I read this Medium post by Dr. Shayla R. Griffin, which I posted my initial reflections on, and which has had an enormous impact on my thinking over the intervening weeks. My […]

    Reply
  2. “Both/And” thinking and Race – #WhatImReading – The Rainie Treatment says:
    12 September 2020 at 8:01 pm

    […] I was reading this chapter, I also came across a Medium article (which heavily influenced my thinking around school reopenings at that time) in which Dr. Shayla R. […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Find posts by topic

administrator anti-racist assessment Books Read bullying change change agent classroom management client conduct conversation coronavirus counseling COVID19 customer service discipline education educator equity etiquette idea innovation leadership learning management parent parenting presentation professionalism public service quarantine questioning racism respect right to education school social contract socialization society stakeholder teacher teaching team teaching What Im Reading white privilege

Find posts by category

Search the archives

  • September 2020 (1)
  • August 2020 (2)
  • July 2020 (5)
  • June 2020 (2)
  • May 2020 (2)
  • August 2019 (3)
  • March 2015 (1)
  • November 2014 (1)
  • April 2014 (3)
  • March 2014 (6)

Recent Posts

  • “Both/And” thinking and Race – #WhatImReading
  • What I’m Reading: “Children and COVID-19: State Data Report”
  • What I’m Reading: “So You Want to Talk About Race” chapter 1
  • What do we need from schools in September?
  • What I’m Reading: “Rich Dad, Poor Dad” by Robert Kiyosaki

Recent Comments

  • “Both/And” thinking and Race – #WhatImReading – The Rainie Treatment on What I’m Reading: Some Students Should Go To School, Most Should Stay Home
  • What I’m Reading: “So You Want to Talk About Race?” chapter 1 – The Rainie Treatment on What I’m Reading: “So You Want To Talk About Race” by Ijeoma Oluo
  • Shepard Rainie on What do we need from schools in September?
  • Diane on What do we need from schools in September?
  • Lisa Goldman on What do we need from schools in September?

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, Rainie Treatment by Damon Rainie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

© 2022 The Rainie Treatment

Powered by Esplanade Theme and WordPress